FreeArc/7-zip/winRAR壓縮小測

j62u6

高級會員
已加入
7/18/06
訊息
823
互動分數
2
點數
18
先來稍微介紹一下FreeArc
FreeArc為一個免費開源,號稱比其他的壓縮軟體壓縮快2~5倍(相同壓縮比下)及會針對不同的檔案自動選擇壓縮演算法來達到更好的壓縮率。
官網:http://www.freearc.org/

測試環境:
懶得打直接看圖
wwww.png

軟體版本
FreeArc 0.666
7-zip 9.20
winRAR 3.93

待壓縮物:
因為真的不知該要拿什麼比較好,所以就拿已經被我增肥的字體資料夾來壓
大小為1.38G 檔案數948
fonts.png


壓縮設定:基本上都是以該軟體預設的最高壓縮設定來壓縮檔案看壓縮結果


FreeArc設定
大同小異的介面
arc.png


壓縮設定,最大壓縮記憶體需求2542MB;ng;(順便說一下他的標準壓縮的壓縮層級是寫7-zip:PPP:)
arc1.png


壓縮在99%暫停截的圖
arc2.png


完成圖:
檔案大小:493MB
壓縮率:34.7%
花費時間:大約在7:50左右
arc3.png


7-zip設定
壓縮設定,極致壓縮記憶體需求709MB
7zip1.png


壓縮在99%暫停截的圖
7zip2.png


完成圖:
檔案大小:519MB
壓縮率:36%
花費時間:大約在8:25左右
7zip3.png


看到這似乎7-zip不管壓縮比還是壓縮速度都輸給了FreeArc,但事實上有一項是FreeArc完全打在地上口吐白沬的;ng;
而那項就是「壓縮速度」,應該有人覺得莫名其妙,明明上面花費時間就比較長壓縮哪有比較快;face12;
那是因為設定上不對的關係

在預設的極致壓縮下選擇的壓縮方式為LZMA,在這方式下CPU 的線程數只有2(最高也只有2)
7zip1.png


但當把壓縮方式改為LZMA2,CPU的隨之衝到我的最高8線程,可是所需的壓縮記憶也暴增到4413MB:PPP:
7zip4.png


在此設定下多核心的價值一整個顯現出來,使用率超高的有如燒機轉檔一般,我的ADDA也開始怒吼了~~~:D
1:25就達到52%感覺之前都是跑心酸的
7zip5.png


在99%暫停截的圖
7zip6.png


完成圖:
檔案大小:525MB
壓縮率:37%
花費時間:大約在3:25左右
7zip7.png


接下來是被我拿來當炮灰的winRAR:PPP:
99%圖
rar.png


完成圖:
檔案大小:683MB
壓縮率:48%
花費時間:大約在3:30左右
rar1.png



小結:
雖然測試的檔案只有單純的字體檔可能有失公允,但從測試的結果可看出,在預設的最高壓
縮情況下FreeArc比起7-zip有最佳的壓縮比及速度。但調整7-zip的壓縮方式為LZMA2後,
雖然壓縮的檔案大小又大了6MB但卻換來了減少了將近5分鐘的壓縮時間,看起來是非常值得
的。
而看似悲情的WINRAR比起速度差不多跟7-zip的LZMA2差不多,但檔案大小卻差上快160MB
更別說FreeArc了,但winRAR的普及率應該毫無疑問遠大於兩者。所以當想追求最小的壓縮比
FreeArc 應該是你最好的選擇,但要同時追求速度卻又不想增加過多的容量7-zip的LZMA2就是
你最佳的夥伴(一整個威啊:D),而winRAR就留給對於電腦不怎麼熟的人吧,丟檔可以減少許多麻煩:PPP:

感謝各位賞臉看完m(_"_)m
 

TAS

"人"生淫家...
已加入
3/16/09
訊息
4,103
互動分數
37
點數
48
WinRAR 4.00 Beta 1
壓縮速度增進了30%喔
中文版還在做
可以去抓英文版來試試
 

j62u6

高級會員
已加入
7/18/06
訊息
823
互動分數
2
點數
18
經TAS大大告知後下了4.00 beta1來試試
但看來沒什麼差別的說
rar403.png

rar40.png

rar402.png
 

TAS

"人"生淫家...
已加入
3/16/09
訊息
4,103
互動分數
37
點數
48
1. RAR decompression speed is improved. Depending on data type,
decompression can be up to 30% faster than in previous versions.

Both the general RAR algorithm and most of special RAR multimedia
methods benefit from this improvement. The only module of RAR
algorithm, which is not affected, is "Text compression" method.

2. Changes in ISO support:

a) UDF support is upgraded to UDF 2.50 revision. It makes possible
to unpack most of Blue-ray ISO files;

b) when browsing UDF ISO file, UDF revision number is displayed
after the "UDF" format name in WinRAR address bar
and in archive information dialog;

c) WinRAR sets the folder modification date when unpacking folders
stored in UDF and ISO9660 files.

3. Changes in password dialog:

a) WinRAR uses the same format of password dialog both when archiving
and extracting, so "Show password" option is available also
when extracting;

b) "Organize passwords..." button in password dialog provides
access to password organizer interface, where you can specify
your frequently used passwords. You will be able to access these
saved passwords using the drop down list or autocomplete feature
in password dialog.

It is important to know that saved passwords are not encrypted
and anybody having access to your computer can view them.
Use "Organize passwords" feature only if your computer is
protected from unauthorized access;

c) "Use for all archives" option is available in password dialog
when unpacking several archives at once. You can utilize it
to apply an entered password to all archives.

If you use this option with an empty password, WinRAR will skip
all encrypted archives.

4. In Windows 7 WinRAR will display the total operation progress
also on WinRAR icon on Windows taskbar. You can disable it using
"Taskbar progress bar" option on "General" page of WinRAR settings.

5. Numerous Unicode support improvements allow to process non-English
file names more smoothly. These improvements include:

a) better Unicode handling in WinRAR in "Rename", "Convert",
"Find" and other commands, in folder tree panel, in password
request dialog and in many other parts of WinRAR interface;

b) correctly displayed Unicode names in WinRAR items in Explorer
context menus;

c) Unicode support in .lng files, making WinRAR localization
possible for Unicode only languages.

6. Changes in -x switch syntax. Now you can specify a wildcard
exclusion mask for folders. Such mask must have the trailing '\'
character, like -x*tmp*\ or -x*\temp\

7. New "Extract relative paths" option in "Advanced" part of extraction
dialog. If you browse some archive subfolder in WinRAR shell
and enable "Extract relative paths" option, the path part up to
and including the current subfolder will be removed from extracted
file paths.

For example, if you are inside of "Backup\MyData" archive folder
and extract "Images" folder, it will be extracted as "Images",
not as "Backup\MyData\Images".

This option is the new default extraction mode, but you can change
the default back to WinRAR 3.x style. Just select "Extract full paths"
and then press "Save settings" in "General" part of extraction dialog.

8. Windows 98, Windows Me and Windows NT are not supported by WinRAR
and WinRAR self-extracting modules anymore. Minimum Windows version
required for WinRAR 4.0 is Windows 2000.

If you need to run WinRAR on older Windows, you can download
previous WinRAR versions from ftp://ftp.rarlab.com/rar

9. If TAR, TAR.GZ or TAR.BZ2 archive contains symbolic or hard links
and if destination file system is NTFS, WinRAR will create these
links when unpacking such archive. WinRAR will create symbolic links
as symbolic and hard links as hard in Windows Vista and newer
and it will create all links as hard in older Windows.

If destination file system is FAT32 or any other not supporting
file links, WinRAR will skip links when unpacking TAR, TAR.GZ
and TAR.BZ2 archives.

10. Recovery volume processing involves less disk seek operations
resulting in higher performance.

11. You can select Windows 7 library in tree panel in extraction dialog
and WinRAR will use its default save location as the destination path.

12. "Report" command allows to select HTML, Unicode text and usual text
as output format for report file. Unlike previous WinRAR versions,
now WinRAR preservers Unicode characters in reports when using HTML
or Unicode text format. So non-English characters in file names
will be displayed properly in such reports.

13. Message list in GUI SFX archives displays only operation status
and error messages. It does not contain names of all extracted files
anymore. This change improves the speed and reduces memory requirements
for SFX archives containing a large number of files. Also it makes
easier to locate error messages, because they are not hidden among
extracted file names.

14. GUI SFX archives display "Extract" button instead of "Install"
if no "Setup" or "Presetup" commands are present in the archive
comment. If you prefer "Install" button, but do not need to
execute any setup programs, you can add "Setup" command
without any parameters.

15. WinRAR displays the current percent above the operation progress bar
when repairing an archive containing the recovery record
and when processing recovery volumes.

16. WinRAR limits the maximum possible volume size to 4 GB minus 1 byte
when creating RAR volumes on a disk with FAT or FAT32 file system
in volume size autodetecting mode. These file systems do not support
4 GB and larger files.

17. If "Wait if other WinRAR copies are active" option is enabled
and WinRAR waits for another copy, you can press "Continue" button
in command progress window to force WinRAR to stop waiting.
So now "Continue" button allows to override the state of
"Wait if other WinRAR copies are active" option for current operation.

18. WinRAR displays one password request instead of two, when saving
an encrypted file back to RAR or ZIP archive after modifying it
in some external editor. Previous WinRAR versions usually requested
the password twice, both when extracting the original file
and archiving its modified copy. Only RAR archives with encrypted
file names were processed with the single password prompt.

19. New error code 10 ("no files") is added to list of error codes
returned in command line mode by RAR and WinRAR. This new code
can be returned by archive, extract, delete and repair commands.
It means that RAR did not find any files matched the specified
file or archive mask.

20. File name area in file overwrite dialog occupies several lines now.
It makes possible to display much longer names.

21. Bugs fixed:

a) renaming a file in archive could also rename all other files
with the same name in other folders of the same archive;

b) previous versions displayed the wrong total packed size
in "Info" command for multivolume CAB archives;

c) in ZIP archives 'U' (update) and 'F' (fresh) commands could
erroneously update even files not specified in the command line.
It happened only for files in current folder which names matched
files in ZIP archive. This bug was not present in usual 'A' (add)
archiving mode.

看錯了...是解壓縮速度依檔案類型最高可增進30%
還有ISO檔的支援變好了..不知道提取速度有沒有變快
還有UNICODE問題終於也有改善
 

j62u6

高級會員
已加入
7/18/06
訊息
823
互動分數
2
點數
18
拿過去準備推甄的資料夾來壓
裡面檔案類別就是些jpg,png,doc跟pdf
因為一樣用預設的,過程我就跳過直接看結果,7-zip小輸6MB

asdf.png


candy999大大能分享一下設定嘛?
 

fjh3uioc

榮譽會員
已加入
2/25/07
訊息
1,261
互動分數
4
點數
38
怎麼沒看到winzip呢
以前最多人用的
 

j62u6

高級會員
已加入
7/18/06
訊息
823
互動分數
2
點數
18
怎麼沒看到winzip呢
以前最多人用的

因再第一次測時就有點悲慘,就沒再繼續測下去
這是用winzip pro 15.0下去測的,格式為zipx的最佳壓縮方式
i62378_zip.png
 

starocean

進階會員
已加入
1/28/05
訊息
236
互動分數
0
點數
0
我還想說試一下
不過看到下面說的


Compared to RAR and 7-zip, FreeArc at this moment lacks the following: multi-volume archives, 64-bit version, storing of file attributes/extended timestamps/NTFS streams in the archive, bcj2, data segmentation. These are planned to be fixed in subsequent versions.
 

sadiku

初級會員
已加入
7/16/07
訊息
7
互動分數
0
點數
0
年齡
48
有人試過freearc的自動解壓縮嗎?我測試的結果是可以壓成exe檔,但解不開,解了很久都解不完。
 
▌延伸閱讀