WD1002FAEX接上eSATA外接盒,遇上ICH9R/10R, JM363, SIL3124, Marvell 88SE9123會有什麼不同? (圖多)

[Day_knight]

一年多前,自己無聊曾簡單地測試當時幾個常見的eSATA控制晶片.經過了這麼久,硬碟傳輸規
格由SATA II/USB 2.0進展到SATA III/USB 3.0,是該更新些新的數據了.;face12;

因為自己先前看了網站相關USB 3.0的測試,似乎對於HD提升效果有限,加上不想多花錢買新
品USB 3.0外接盒來玩,就請大家查閱網路相關測試或howdeng大大最新的測試報告,此篇
就專注於eSATA的測試.


測試環境:

M/B: P6X58D Premium (ICH10R+Marvell 88SE9123 SATA3 6Gb/s)
P5K-E (ICH9R+JMicron 363)
擴充卡: Silicon Image 3124 PCI-e卡
eSATA外接盒: ICY DOCK 中銨MB559
OS: Vista x64 SP2 中英文版
Driver: Intel IMM 8.9, Marvell v1.0.0.1027, JMicron v1.17.53.0

測試軟體:ATTO Disk Benchmark v2.46, CrystalDiskMark, FastCopy, HDTune PRO, HDTach等如下

由於ICY DOCK接WD1002FAEX,搭配多數控制晶片,都可以使用預設值(6Gb/s)去測試,但實際失
上跑來可能只約eSATA 3Gb/s值,卻對Marvell 88SE9123 AHCI模式下,跑6Gb/s會自動離線,只
能先將HD強制設成3Gb/s去跑測試,以下Marvell 88SE9123相關測試均以SATA 3Gb/s測試.


還是一樣先從常見的HDTune v4.01來測試

HDTune Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune FileBenchmark on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune FileBenchmark on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Random Access Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Random Access Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Random Access Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Random Access Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Extra Test Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Extra Test Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Extra Test Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Extra Test Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

分段發,未完待續......

 

[Day_knight]

接著HDTach相關軟體,HDTach對於Marvell的Driver似乎有點怪異,所以導致某些數據
會異常飆高,以往的模範生Jmicron Driver對於新版的SATA 6Gb/s HD似乎也會有異常
的數據,期待廠商有解決

HD-Tach RW Quick Read/Write Test on ICH9R

HD-Tach RW Quick Read/Write Test on ICH10R

HD-Tach RW Quick Read/Write Test on JM363

HD-Tach RW Quick Read/Write Test on SIL3124

HD-Tach RW Quick Read/Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HD-Tach RW Long Read/Write Test on ICH9R

HD-Tach RW Long Read/Write Test on ICH10R

HD-Tach RW Long Read/Write Test on JM363

HD-Tach RW Long Read/Write Test on SIL3124

HD-Tach RW Long Read/Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HD-Tach Quick Read Test on ICH9R

HD-Tach Quick Read Test on ICH10R

HD-Tach Quick Read Test on JM363

HD-Tach Quick Read Test on SIL3124

HD-Tach Quick Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HD-Tach Long Read Test on ICH9R

HD-Tach Long Read Test on ICH10R

HD-Tach Long Read Test on JM363

HD-Tach Long Read Test on SIL3124

HD-Tach Long Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

Everest DiskBenchmark on ICH9R

Everest DiskBenchmark on ICH10R

Everest DiskBenchmark on JM363

Everest DiskBenchmark on SIL3124

Everest DiskBenchmark on Marvell 88SE9123

分段發,未完待續......

 

[Day_knight]

PCWizard 2010 Diskbenchmark on ICH9R

PCWizard 2010 Diskbenchmark on ICH10R

PCWizard 2010 Diskbenchmark on JM363

PCWizard 2010 Diskbenchmark on SIL3124

PCWizard 2010 Diskbenchmark on Marvell 88SE9123

Crystal DiskMarK 50M on ICH9/10R, JM363 & SIL3124

Crystal DiskMarK 50M on Marvell 88SE9123

Crystal DiskMarK 100M on ICH9/10R, JM363 & SIL3124

Crystal DiskMarK 100M on Marvell 88SE9123

Crystal DiskMarK 500M on ICH9/10R, JM363 & SIL3124

Crystal DiskMarK 500M on Marvell 88SE9123

Crystal DiskMarK 1000M on ICH9/10R, JM363 & SIL3124

Crystal DiskMarK 1000M on Marvell 88SE9123

FDBench v1.02 100M/1M測試

FDBench v1.02 2000M/40M測試

分段發,未完待續......

 

[Day_knight]

很紅的ATTO DiskBenchmark也拿來測看看好了,去官網抓了最新的v2.46.考慮到這顆HD的
Cache是64M,所以直接測256M~2G的測試,256M以下的值就不加入測試,敬請見諒.


ATTO DiskBench 256M Test on ICH9/10R

ATTO DiskBench 256M Test on JM363/SIL3124

ATTO DiskBench 256M Test on Marvell 88SE9123

ATTO DiskBench 512M Test on ICH9/10R

ATTO DiskBench 512M Test on JM363/SIL3124

ATTO DiskBench 512M Test on Marvell 88SE9123

ATTO DiskBench 1G Test on ICH9/10R

ATTO DiskBench 1G Test on JM363/SIL3124

ATTO DiskBench 1G Test on Marvell 88SE9123

ATTO DiskBench 2G Test on ICH9/10R

ATTO DiskBench 2G Test on JM363/SIL3124

ATTO DiskBench 2G Test on Marvell 88SE9123

分段發,未完待續......

 

[BANANA~]

看來是ICH9R及ICH10R有最佳的平均讀寫速率
Marvell及Jmicron的晶片上緩衝速率會報高...
但在Marvell的讀取速率看來是較漂亮的

期待您的後續測試，發文辛苦了

 

[TAS]

等表...記得準備感謝欄我等著丟:D

 

[Day_knight]

最後仍是進入平常實用的大檔案傳輸測試,同樣地改用FastCopy 1.99r4當測試基準,將一
個6.61G的資料夾對傳,這個資料夾由大的ISO檔及幾個小檔所組合成.

考慮到WD1002FAEX是單碟500G的組合,就拿另一個單碟500G的
WD5000AAKS-00M9A0 藍標500G來做檔案對傳測試,雖不盡理想,但也希望能比較藍標
與黑標的差異;em28;惟因兩顆HD的Cache容量分別為16MB及64MB,所以分別對
FastCopy設定16MB及64MB的設定值進行測試


FastCopy 16M WD500AAKS Copy 到WD1002FAEX on ICH9/10R, JM363/SIL3124測試

FastCopy 16M WD500AAKS Copy 到WD1002FAEX on Marvell 88SE9123測試

FastCopy 64M WD500AAKS Copy 到WD1002FAEX on ICH9/10R, JM363/SIL3124測試

FastCopy 64M WD500AAKS Copy 到WD1002FAEX on Marvell 88SE9123測試

FastCopy 16M WD1002FAEX Copy 到WD5000AAKS on ICH9/10R, JM363/SIL3124測試

FastCopy 16M WD1002FAEX Copy 到WD5000AAKS on Marvell 88SE9123測試

FastCopy 64M WD1002FAEX Copy 到WD5000AAKS on ICH9/10R, JM363/SIL3124測試

FastCopy 64M WD1002FAEX Copy 到WD5000AAKS on Marvell 88SE9123測試

測試心得...

1.目前雖沒eSATA 6Gb/s的外接盒可用,但若手中持有的eSATA外接盒可上到eSATA 3Gb/s的
話,暫時沒有必要急著換USB 3.0外接盒,畢竟傳輸率相差不大,且USB 3.0對於HD的傳輸率也
不能拉高,所以省點錢吧,在此也謝謝其它測試USB 3.0的前輩們.

2.Silicon Image 3124雖然是一個蠻早的晶片,但歷經這麼多代,感覺它的傳輸穩定仍得以維持,
真的是不可多得的好產品,只是無法保證其它市售SIL3124是否也有同樣的效果.

3.最後仍是期待廠商推出eSATA 6Gb/s外接盒,或是廠商針對前面的Bug能有改進.


假日在家忙了一天半測試相關數據真的很累,短期內應該不會再測了,除非有更新的玩具出來.;oq;

 

[阿正正]

超繁雜的測試，真是辛苦你了

9R 10R幾乎是一樣的，除了可RAID數量不同以外大概都沒差了
INTEL真的是很愛搞分級

 

[yewk]

測試文看得很混亂!!!我結論看得很清楚!!真是辛苦大大測試了!!

 

[Day_knight]

圖床流量爆了,自己找到新圖床重新上傳一次

HDTune Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123
http://5.share.photo.xuite.net/ralphyang/1522e86/3881228/148040570_L.jpg

HDTune Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune FileBenchmark on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune FileBenchmark on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Random Access Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Random Access Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Random Access Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Random Access Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Extra Test Read Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Extra Test Read Test on Marvell 88SE9123

HDTune Extra Test Write Test on ICH9/10R及JM363/SIL3124

HDTune Extra Test Write Test on Marvell 88SE9123